Environmental Calculator:

<

General Overview of Background and Methods



The guidelines presented in the "Eco-Design Guidelines"-section will give general advice, but they cannot answer questions like:

The first solution uses raw materials and involves more labour in the production phase, whilst the other solution consumes electricity in the use phase.


To be able to weigh out such alternatives against each other, the section 'Environmental Calculator' is used. It relies on a database with figures representing a simplified environmental impact assessment, using two parameters to describe the impacts (e.g. by using an integrated circuit, x gram of aluminium or consuming y kWh of electricity):

The Environmental Calculator enables the designer to compare the environmental impacts in the whole life cycle of different design alternatives, and this can be done already in the concept phase, with very few data available and before the design has been finalised.

The database also contains:



Energy parameter (E-parameter)

The Energy parameter is an indicator of the draw on the global energy reserve, which with the present energy sources is declining.

It is also an indicator of the pollution resulting from an average global energy application; e.g. global warming gases, acidifying gases, gases contributing to nutrient enrichment, waste in the form of slag and in the form of radioactive wastes (from nuclear power plants).


The Energy parameter is an aggregation of the total life cycle energy measured as primary energy in MJ. This is the sum of the 'Net Calorific Value' (Material Energy) and the energy used for manufacturing (process energy). These values can be calculated by means of a LCA-tool, e.g. the Danish EDIP PC-Tool, which has been used for calculation of default values applied in Environmental Calculator I and II.



Resource parameter (R-parameter)

When a certain material is used for instance in a product, it means that the remaining virgin resources of this material has been diminished. Dependent on the scarcity of the resource, this is more or less serious.

The purpose of the Resource parameter is:

The Resource parameter is an indicator of the total non-energy draw on virgin resources. Energy resources are covered by the Energy parameter and are therefore excluded from the Resource parameter.


Calculation of the Resource parameter

The resource consumption (of e.g. copper) is divided by the known global reserves (of copper) per person. 1990 is used as reference year. See table 'World Reserves Life Index'.

Example:

PR (person-reserves) are therefore also the unit for the R parameter for the product to which all the individual contributions are added.

The Resource and Energy scores used in this tool is one way to quantify the first two rows in the MECO system.


Example:

Resource Life Cycle consumption (kg) Known global res. 1990 (kg/person) Ri (mPR)
Al 0.8 660 1.21
Cu 0.3 60 5
Ag 0.001 0.15 6.67
Zn 0.075 30 2.5


R = RAl + RCu + RAg + RZn = 15.38 mPR

More information (and suggested literature) may be found in the LCA-section.



Warning! Use the calculators with care - pitfalls

Before applying the environmental calculator tools, it is highly recommendable to read the LCA section in the Green tutorial and to understand the meaning of 'functional unit' and 'allocation'.

Life time

If the tools are applied for comparing sub-product alternatives (as for instance whether cooling most conveniently can be carried out by application of cooling fans or convection cooling), it is important to consider, whether one of the systems will affect the entire lifetime of the product.

If it is assumed that the lifetime is considerably affected by the cooling choice, the assessment should be carried out at the product level.

Data quality

The data on electronics components are highly generic and extrapolations within component groups have been made roughly by mass scaling. Extrapolation has also been carried out between similar component groups, as data have not yet been obtained for all types of components. Future versions of the design-guide will up-date these data as they become available.

The database only covers a relatively limited number of processes, modes of transportation and energy scenarios. When applying the tools, the most relevant processes should be applied, but the result should therefore be interpreted accordingly with care.

Chemical lists

One possible output from 'Environmental calculator II' is the presence of the products contents of substances on different chemical lists. This survey is not complete due to a number of reasons. Please refer to 'Methods to measure and improve Environmental Performance with regards to Chemicals' for further explanations on chemicals.

Comparing E- and R-parameters

An interpretation challenge arises when comparing two design-alternatives, where the E- and R-parameter scores for instance are the following:

Product-example E-parameter [MJ] R-parameter [mPR]
Alternative 1
915
5,6
Alternative 2
470
15,2


Alternative 1 has the highest E- and the lowest R-parameter, while alternative 2 has the lowest E-, but the highest R-parameter. So the question is: which one is from an environmental point of view the most attractive?

The fact is, that the E- and R-parameters are two different environmental measurement-values, with different measurement-units (Mega-Joule and Person-Reserves), and they are not comparable and cannot be combined into one single figure.

As both parameters expresses the magnitude of environmental load from a given product or part of a product, a joint reduction of the E- and R-parameters should be aimed at when applying the calculator.




<